The Re-Commitment Trap

In the church I was raised, it was a common occurrence for the pastor to invite people to respond to a message by re-committing their lives to Jesus.  Many times under the conviction of sin I raised my hand or went forward in acknowledgement of my sin and desire to repent.  It is never hard for born-again Christians to see their need for repentance and forgiveness.  We could not be born-again again, so re-commitment was posed as the way back to God for a backslider.  This concept of re-commitment became an endless loop which rested on nothing more than my own resolve and self-control which always fell short.

There is a place for renewal and revival in the life of Christians, but I am convinced the option of re-commitment modeled for me in my youth misses the point.  The more I think about it, the more I am certain the idea of re-commitment is without biblical precedent.  Should Christians commit and entrust themselves to God in faith?  Yes.  But commitment can be independent of faith; it can be empty words of the self-deceived who refuse to repent.  Re-committing to God is not repenting of sin before God.  The biggest issue I have with re-commitment in response to conviction of sin is it is only one side of the coin:  the focus is entirely on me and my best efforts rather than reliance upon God and all Christ has accomplished.

God is more than "committed" to us, for He established an everlasting covenant with the shed blood of Jesus Christ.  When we are convicted for sin and made aware of our backsliding, the call is to return to God in repentance.  If every time we were convicted of sin we "re-committed" our lives to Jesus it is little more than a pledge from a hardened felon.  And that is why when re-commitment is an option, it never seems to stick.  We have not truly repented because we did not need to.  All that was required in that moment of soul-searching was to respond with raising a hand, walking to the front of the church, or seeking prayer and the pressure was relieved.  Having done something we were back in good standing with God again and life continued on as usual--that is, until being called out the following Sunday.

What is tricky about following Jesus is that in a sense it IS a commitment, but again this is only part of the equation.  Better than telling God what we will do, we should confess before God how we have failed and ask forgiveness on the basis of the covenant He has already made with us.  For those in the re-commitment rut their salvation often seems to hinge on their performance rather than receiving the grace of God through His promise.  If we are indeed born again and filled with the Holy Spirit, having been adopted as a child of God by grace through faith in Him, we ought to respond with the humility of the prodigal son in the parable who returned to his father.  He did not come back pledging to do a better job or to make up for his folly:  he said, "I have sinned."  He was filled with a sense of unworthiness and begged to be permitted to serve as a slave but his father hugged and received him as a beloved son.

If you find yourself caught in a perpetual backsliding re-commitment trap, there is hope in Jesus Christ.  Instead of pledging to do better, repent and return to Jesus Christ.  Only God can make a new creation and empower you to walk in the way that fully pleases Him.  Re-commitment is an empty hope based on our feeble efforts, but in Jesus Christ and in His covenant there is strong confidence.